| Chiefs Past to Present |
| George S. Graves 1875 - 1876 |
| Charles Blood 1876 - 1881 |
| John Gilson 1881 – 1884 |
| George S. Graves 1884 – 1886 |
| Charles Woolley 1886 – 1892 |
| Lewis F. Williams 1892 – 1893 |
| Henry W. Whiting 1893 – 1898 |
| Fred A. Sherwin 1898 – 1901 |
| Frank M. Blood 1901 – 1906 |
| James B. Harrington 1906 – 1914 |
| Michael F. McGowan 1914 – 1921 |
| M. Joseph Cleary 1921 – 1945 |
| Robert M. May 1945 – 1964 |
| John R. Friedrich 1964 – 1972 |
| Bennett R. Black 1972 – 1982 |
| James J. Connolly 1982 – 1994 |
| Christopher J. Kelley 1994 – 1999 |
| Joseph Bosselait 2000 - 2014 |
| Steele McCurdy 2014 - 2024 |
| Arthur Cheeks 2024 - |